Skip to content Skip to footer

When considering a bathroom remodel, one of the primary decisions you’ll face is whether to install a bathtub, a shower, or both. This choice significantly impacts the functionality, aesthetics, and overall appeal of your bathroom. Each option has its advantages and considerations, making it essential to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.

The Versatility of Showers

Showers have gained popularity in modern bathroom designs for several reasons:

  1. Space-Saving Solution: Showers tend to take up less space than bathtubs, making them ideal for smaller bathrooms or for those looking to maximize space efficiently.

  2. Accessibility: Showers provide easier accessibility, particularly for individuals with mobility issues or for aging homeowners who might find it challenging to step in and out of a bathtub.

  3. Efficiency: They are generally more water-efficient than bathtubs, as they consume less water during use, contributing to lower utility bills and environmental conservation efforts.

  4. Variety of Designs: Showers offer diverse design options, from walk-in showers to enclosed stalls with various materials and finishes, providing ample opportunities for customization to suit personal preferences and style.

  5. Quick and Convenient: Showers are ideal for individuals with busy lifestyles, as they offer a quick and convenient way to freshen up.

bathroom renovation

The Allure of Bathtubs

Bathtubs, on the other hand, come with their own set of advantages:

  1. Relaxation and Luxury: Soaking in a bathtub can provide a relaxing and luxurious experience, allowing individuals to unwind and de-stress after a long day. Options like whirlpool or soaking tubs enhance this experience further.

  2. Versatility: Bathtubs cater to various preferences, offering choices such as alcove, freestanding, or corner tubs, allowing homeowners to choose based on available space and desired aesthetic.

  3. Ideal for Families: For households with young children or pets, bathtubs are often seen as more practical for bathing kids or washing pets due to their design and depth.

  4. Home Resale Value: In some cases, having at least one bathtub in the home might increase its resale value, as it caters to a wider range of potential buyers who prefer having a tub.

  5. Spa-Like Experience: Advanced features like hydrotherapy, air jets, or chromotherapy in certain tubs provide a spa-like experience at home.

bathroom renovation price

Factors Influencing Your Decision

Several factors should be taken into consideration when deciding between a tub and a shower during a bathroom remodel:

  1. Space: Assess the available space in your bathroom. If space is limited, a shower might be the more practical choice. However, if you have ample space, you might consider incorporating both a bathtub and a shower.

  2. Lifestyle and Preferences: Consider your lifestyle and bathing habits. Do you prefer a quick shower or a long soak in a tub? This personal preference plays a crucial role in the decision-making process.

  3. Family Needs: If you have a family or plan to start one, a bathtub might be essential, especially for bathing children.

  4. Resale Value: Evaluate the potential impact on the resale value of your home. In some real estate markets, having at least one bathtub can be more appealing to potential buyers.

  5. Budget: Consider your budget and the associated costs of installing and maintaining both options. Generally, showers tend to be more cost-effective than bathtubs, but luxurious shower designs might increase the overall cost.


Choosing between a bathtub and a shower for your bathroom remodel is a personal decision influenced by various factors. Assess your needs, space availability, lifestyle, and budget constraints before making a choice. Some homeowners opt for a compromise by incorporating a shower-tub combination that provides the benefits of both options.

Ultimately, whether you lean towards the convenience and efficiency of a shower or the relaxation and luxury of a bathtub, your decision should align with your preferences and lifestyle, creating a bathroom space that best suits your needs and brings comfort and enjoyment to your daily routine.